| name | character |
|
Roman Arabia
|
Luis Cruz
|
|
Adam Brock
|
Band Lead Singer
|
|
Andy Buckley
|
Uncle Matthew
|
|
Derek Butler
|
"Merrily We Roll Along" Performer
|
|
Cynthia Cales
|
Immaculate Heart of Mary Teacher
|
|
Timothée Chalamet
|
Kyle Scheible
|
|
Kristen Cloke
|
Ms. Steffans
|
|
Erik Daniells
|
"Merrily We Roll Along" Performer
|
|
Marietta DePrima
|
Miss Patty
|
|
Monique Edwards
|
NYC Nurse
|
|
Ithamar Enriquez
|
Driving Instructor
|
|
Beanie Feldstein
|
Julianne "Julie" Steffans
|
|
Robert Figueroa
|
Cast Removal Doctor
|
|
Bayne Gibby
|
Casey Kelly
|
|
Gurpreet Gill
|
Convenience Store Clerk
|
|
Giselle Grams
|
Immaculate Heart of Mary Teacher
|
|
Lucas Hedges
|
Danny O'Neill
|
|
Stephen Henderson
|
Father Leviatch
|
|
Anita Kalathara
|
Prom Chairwoman
|
|
John Karna
|
Greg Anrue
|
|
Abhimanyu Katyal
|
Friendly Banker
|
|
Paul Keller
|
Parish Priest
|
|
Ben Konigsberg
|
David From College
|
|
Luisa Lee
|
Young Lady
|
|
Tracy Letts
|
Larry McPherson
|